Let me know in the comments. Cookbook is in.
I'll be emailing you on a situation I'm facing tonight/tomorrow.
Showing posts with label librarianship is my bad boyfriend. Show all posts
Showing posts with label librarianship is my bad boyfriend. Show all posts
Monday, January 23, 2012
Sunday, January 22, 2012
So Kerry, What Are You Up To?
Last weekend I went to North Carolina to visit Genevieve!
She gave birth to her daughter Lucy at the beginning of December, and I went to meet the new baby. Lucy is lovely--so tiny, with almond shaped eyes and Genevieve's nose and a little fuzz of dark hair. And beautiful long fingers! We didn't do much aside from visiting the cheese shop and hanging out--when a baby is so small it is just good to have extra hands to hold the baby. And of course I visited with Benjamin, my favorite 3 year old. He is so creative and very into superheroes these days. Why am I so tempted to buy copies of the Powerpuff Girls complete series for both him and Peaches?
Aside from that, I apply for jobs and think of blog posts, but don't blog because I feel guilty of not applying for EVERY SINGLE JOB OUT THERE THAT I AM NOT QUALIFIED FOR. So instead I seem to fall into watching Netflix and Hulu. Feel free to call me up and holler at me.
But I have a phone interview for a job tomorrow. I have mixed thoughts about going for this--it's $12/hr, 5 hours a night Monday through Friday, 5-10pm each night. I'd have to get my hands on transportation because the bus doesn't run that late. But it's an interview, right? And in the library field (MLIS required assistant position at a for-profit college). So good vibes at 2pm Mountain Time would be appreciated.
She gave birth to her daughter Lucy at the beginning of December, and I went to meet the new baby. Lucy is lovely--so tiny, with almond shaped eyes and Genevieve's nose and a little fuzz of dark hair. And beautiful long fingers! We didn't do much aside from visiting the cheese shop and hanging out--when a baby is so small it is just good to have extra hands to hold the baby. And of course I visited with Benjamin, my favorite 3 year old. He is so creative and very into superheroes these days. Why am I so tempted to buy copies of the Powerpuff Girls complete series for both him and Peaches?
Aside from that, I apply for jobs and think of blog posts, but don't blog because I feel guilty of not applying for EVERY SINGLE JOB OUT THERE THAT I AM NOT QUALIFIED FOR. So instead I seem to fall into watching Netflix and Hulu. Feel free to call me up and holler at me.
But I have a phone interview for a job tomorrow. I have mixed thoughts about going for this--it's $12/hr, 5 hours a night Monday through Friday, 5-10pm each night. I'd have to get my hands on transportation because the bus doesn't run that late. But it's an interview, right? And in the library field (MLIS required assistant position at a for-profit college). So good vibes at 2pm Mountain Time would be appreciated.
Sunday, December 11, 2011
I Feel All Lucky And Blessed
Okay first off, I have a job interview on Wednesday. It was the capper of a great week in which I left the house and had fun a lot--more on those adventures later. It's for a job that while I may be overqualified for it and it represents a step back on my resume, it has a lot of side quality-of-life benefits: it's on the 29 bus route, it's back in the library world, it would probably allow me to meet a lot of interesting people and directly engage with them, a good schedule, and you know, it's WORK.
I think that in 2012 I should direct my self-improvement/therapy efforts on trying to figure out my career. I don't want to work for crazy people who make me feel anxious and bad about myself, but it really seems like I've got a thing for finding such positions and getting trapped in them. Not to mention, I am the queen of "just jobs" and the whole librarian thing is impossible.
Or maybe I should just let Terry the T-Rex run my career. I imagine her advice would involve a lot of teeth baring and running down the weak.
Additionally, tonight Aces is performing for pay and possibly using jokes we co-wrote last week about porn and the Kitten Party DVD I took out of the library. I am having a dinner beforehand with The Huntress and Winter at my house. I will probably make chicken soft tacos. I made them about 2 years ago for The Huntress and brought them in for lunch, and she still talks about them! And I will probably also make a marmalade cake.
I think that in 2012 I should direct my self-improvement/therapy efforts on trying to figure out my career. I don't want to work for crazy people who make me feel anxious and bad about myself, but it really seems like I've got a thing for finding such positions and getting trapped in them. Not to mention, I am the queen of "just jobs" and the whole librarian thing is impossible.
Or maybe I should just let Terry the T-Rex run my career. I imagine her advice would involve a lot of teeth baring and running down the weak.
Additionally, tonight Aces is performing for pay and possibly using jokes we co-wrote last week about porn and the Kitten Party DVD I took out of the library. I am having a dinner beforehand with The Huntress and Winter at my house. I will probably make chicken soft tacos. I made them about 2 years ago for The Huntress and brought them in for lunch, and she still talks about them! And I will probably also make a marmalade cake.
Wednesday, November 02, 2011
Chapped Hands, Broken Nails, And A Successful Afternoon
Today I did my first shift at the library as a volunteer. "Kerry! How are you putting your MLIS to work?" Dear readers, they do not let you do professional work as a volunteer. That is why the whole "Can't get hired? Volunteer!" advice that gets handed to library school graduates is such bullshit.
I am shelving. Which I knew getting into this gig, and am perfectly fine with. I get to shelve the nonfiction, which has the advantage that it's tricky in terms of Dewey and keeping the numbers in order, so a book cart took me 2 hours. Also as I was shelving, I was straightening shelves and shifting, and reshelving anything I noticed out of place. I told my supervisor that I was happy to love on my section.
I checked out only one book out that I found of interest. Such restraint! And I broke just 2 nails. I should have polished them before heading over, but I forgot that even a little exposure to books and paper chemicals sucks the moisture out of your hands and nails.Then I came home and had a huge drink.
I'll be there every Thursday morning, 11am-1pm. May this be the catnip to employers that I need to get some interviews.
I am shelving. Which I knew getting into this gig, and am perfectly fine with. I get to shelve the nonfiction, which has the advantage that it's tricky in terms of Dewey and keeping the numbers in order, so a book cart took me 2 hours. Also as I was shelving, I was straightening shelves and shifting, and reshelving anything I noticed out of place. I told my supervisor that I was happy to love on my section.
I checked out only one book out that I found of interest. Such restraint! And I broke just 2 nails. I should have polished them before heading over, but I forgot that even a little exposure to books and paper chemicals sucks the moisture out of your hands and nails.Then I came home and had a huge drink.
I'll be there every Thursday morning, 11am-1pm. May this be the catnip to employers that I need to get some interviews.
Saturday, March 21, 2009
Satire or Serious? Librarian Edition
Click on the link in the header, and answer me this--do you think that letter writer is being serious?
I do. And that letter disturbs me. It disturbs me that there's someone out there who will brag that she can't afford a damn second banana because she is so self-sacrificing. It disturbs me that American Libraries would publish that letter as matter of factly as it does. And it disturbs me that librarians recognize it immediately as being serious, because we all know someone who is like that and recognize that that attitude is encouraged and rewarded within the profession.
I have said before that I don't see myself going back to being a librarian, especially since I made 20% than I would as an entry level professional. Yes, I have a mercenary side, but I also like the validation that my pink collar combination of hard analytical skills combined with the ability to get people to talk to me and trust me has value. Because too often when your skills fall into that dimension, your mental fallback is that the only thing you can do other than whatever job you currently have is be a secretary or work at Sonic.
When the meeting about layoffs happened, The Auditor General explained why she made the decision to cut jobs instead of trying to cut salaries or do furloughs. One of the reasons really struck me--she said in the future, if and when things get better, she can go back to the legislature and ask for funding to replace people due to need. She can't go back and get them to raise our pay when we sold ourselves cheaply and easily. (I'm paraphrasing here, but you get the drift).
And that increased my respect and trust for her. And my gratitude that I wound up in this job, which I still regard as a bit of a fluke.
Because in the library world, we're often treated poorly by the people we serve. We're also treated poorly by our leaders. They raise their hands and say "What can I do?" as they deprofessionalize positions, cry they can't raise salaries, spend endless times in committees and meetings that take years to accomplish nothing, and then say they can't find adequate applicants and continually recruit for the MLS.
Good people with strong work ethics and skills are worthy of respect. It's not entitled or arrogant to think that you have worth. What's arrogant is treating people badly and thinking they'll stick around for it.
I do. And that letter disturbs me. It disturbs me that there's someone out there who will brag that she can't afford a damn second banana because she is so self-sacrificing. It disturbs me that American Libraries would publish that letter as matter of factly as it does. And it disturbs me that librarians recognize it immediately as being serious, because we all know someone who is like that and recognize that that attitude is encouraged and rewarded within the profession.
I have said before that I don't see myself going back to being a librarian, especially since I made 20% than I would as an entry level professional. Yes, I have a mercenary side, but I also like the validation that my pink collar combination of hard analytical skills combined with the ability to get people to talk to me and trust me has value. Because too often when your skills fall into that dimension, your mental fallback is that the only thing you can do other than whatever job you currently have is be a secretary or work at Sonic.
When the meeting about layoffs happened, The Auditor General explained why she made the decision to cut jobs instead of trying to cut salaries or do furloughs. One of the reasons really struck me--she said in the future, if and when things get better, she can go back to the legislature and ask for funding to replace people due to need. She can't go back and get them to raise our pay when we sold ourselves cheaply and easily. (I'm paraphrasing here, but you get the drift).
And that increased my respect and trust for her. And my gratitude that I wound up in this job, which I still regard as a bit of a fluke.
Because in the library world, we're often treated poorly by the people we serve. We're also treated poorly by our leaders. They raise their hands and say "What can I do?" as they deprofessionalize positions, cry they can't raise salaries, spend endless times in committees and meetings that take years to accomplish nothing, and then say they can't find adequate applicants and continually recruit for the MLS.
Good people with strong work ethics and skills are worthy of respect. It's not entitled or arrogant to think that you have worth. What's arrogant is treating people badly and thinking they'll stick around for it.
Thursday, February 19, 2009
More Crappy Library Job Advice
Why You Should Consider That Job In Smalltown, USA
Sigh. Let me count the flawed assumptions in the premise of this article.
1) It assumes those Smalltown jobs don't have applicants. I can’t believe this, based purely on my own feel for the number of library school graduates in the country versus the number of entry level-ish jobs I see posted. Not to mention how a pretty standard piece of library job hunting advice is the blithe “Apply for any job, anywhere!” There’s a lot of applicants per job. If the jobs are not getting applicants, there might be many reasons other than just location. They may not be advertising anywhere but on their town HR page or the state library association website. They might not be offering a salary that's enough to live on even in that small town, where the cost of living may be low but a second job would be unavailable. It might have red flags all over the place for applicants. It may in fact be an easily recognizable crap job for reasons that have nothing to do with location.
2) Speaking of which, while library job hunters are constantly told to be flexible and apply anywhere, a lot of people who do that never seem to be taken seriously as applicants unless they live in the area. Which yes, I know about the decentralized and diverse library world, but for the love of god MAKE UP YOUR MINDS.
Oh, and be respectful. If someone applies, take her at her word that she will pack up and move to the great beyond and treat her as a serious candidate no matter where she lives until she indicates otherwise.
3) If they don't have applicants they like, maybe there needs to be an adjustment of expectations on both sides. You get the pool you advertise for at the price you want. I really cannot believe the arrogance of libraries that think they should get the sun, the moon and the stars for a tuppence. Believe me, I’m sorry they can’t afford to pay workers more. But then when people get other jobs that use their skill set and pay more, why should they be faulted for seeking the best deal for themselves that they can get?
4) It also assumes that you as an applicant should not be so gosh-darned picky and be grateful for a job anywhere.
Here's the thing--I have been not picky. Not picky in love, not picky in jobs, not picky in friends.
It made me miserable. It sapped my effectiveness. And in the end, it didn't work out. I really don’t do so well reveling in misery. It’s a cozy trap, but still a trap.
Back before I graduated I applied for a couple of middle of nowhere jobs. But then I stopped because I realized that I don't want to live far away from my family in a place where I don't know anyone and where the only outlet of friendliness is work. It would have imported the misery of my Cleveland life to a new location. I don't like being miserable, and frankly it takes so very little to make me happy. So I moved to a place where I have support and love, sun and free grapefruit, and gave up on using my degree in that way. It was a decent tradeoff.
5) The second career problem—look, those small town jobs are great if you’re a young single person with few attachments. Not so good if you have a husband and kids, and that husband has a career of his own.
Who does librarianship like to pitch itself to? People looking for a new career. Where are there a plethora of unfilled entry level jobs? (Supposedly--I actually doubt this.) Small towns. See how this does not match up? Why would a couple decide to sacrifice opportunities for the person whose career is more established and quite possibly has a better earning potential?
But again it goes back to the issue of sexism in the profession. I've mentioned this before, but others have said it too--librarianship seems to like to assume you're married so you can do good, fulfilling, low paying work with the safety net of a man's wallet instead of your own full purse. But face it--economic power, especially now, counts most.
6) Your skills atrophy when you don't have the chance to sharpen them with competition and communication. It's going to be harder to find that in a small town where you have to work harder at making professional connections and finding different problems to solve.
Look, the reason I get so worked up about these issues is that I see librarians hiding in vagaries instead of applying critical thinking to the field and its employment prospects and giving accurate advice to people. It may be that the field is so diffuse it's impossible to give instructional advice. If so, quit acting like what you have to say has anything to do with the real world.
Sigh. Let me count the flawed assumptions in the premise of this article.
1) It assumes those Smalltown jobs don't have applicants. I can’t believe this, based purely on my own feel for the number of library school graduates in the country versus the number of entry level-ish jobs I see posted. Not to mention how a pretty standard piece of library job hunting advice is the blithe “Apply for any job, anywhere!” There’s a lot of applicants per job. If the jobs are not getting applicants, there might be many reasons other than just location. They may not be advertising anywhere but on their town HR page or the state library association website. They might not be offering a salary that's enough to live on even in that small town, where the cost of living may be low but a second job would be unavailable. It might have red flags all over the place for applicants. It may in fact be an easily recognizable crap job for reasons that have nothing to do with location.
2) Speaking of which, while library job hunters are constantly told to be flexible and apply anywhere, a lot of people who do that never seem to be taken seriously as applicants unless they live in the area. Which yes, I know about the decentralized and diverse library world, but for the love of god MAKE UP YOUR MINDS.
Oh, and be respectful. If someone applies, take her at her word that she will pack up and move to the great beyond and treat her as a serious candidate no matter where she lives until she indicates otherwise.
3) If they don't have applicants they like, maybe there needs to be an adjustment of expectations on both sides. You get the pool you advertise for at the price you want. I really cannot believe the arrogance of libraries that think they should get the sun, the moon and the stars for a tuppence. Believe me, I’m sorry they can’t afford to pay workers more. But then when people get other jobs that use their skill set and pay more, why should they be faulted for seeking the best deal for themselves that they can get?
4) It also assumes that you as an applicant should not be so gosh-darned picky and be grateful for a job anywhere.
Here's the thing--I have been not picky. Not picky in love, not picky in jobs, not picky in friends.
It made me miserable. It sapped my effectiveness. And in the end, it didn't work out. I really don’t do so well reveling in misery. It’s a cozy trap, but still a trap.
Back before I graduated I applied for a couple of middle of nowhere jobs. But then I stopped because I realized that I don't want to live far away from my family in a place where I don't know anyone and where the only outlet of friendliness is work. It would have imported the misery of my Cleveland life to a new location. I don't like being miserable, and frankly it takes so very little to make me happy. So I moved to a place where I have support and love, sun and free grapefruit, and gave up on using my degree in that way. It was a decent tradeoff.
5) The second career problem—look, those small town jobs are great if you’re a young single person with few attachments. Not so good if you have a husband and kids, and that husband has a career of his own.
Who does librarianship like to pitch itself to? People looking for a new career. Where are there a plethora of unfilled entry level jobs? (Supposedly--I actually doubt this.) Small towns. See how this does not match up? Why would a couple decide to sacrifice opportunities for the person whose career is more established and quite possibly has a better earning potential?
But again it goes back to the issue of sexism in the profession. I've mentioned this before, but others have said it too--librarianship seems to like to assume you're married so you can do good, fulfilling, low paying work with the safety net of a man's wallet instead of your own full purse. But face it--economic power, especially now, counts most.
6) Your skills atrophy when you don't have the chance to sharpen them with competition and communication. It's going to be harder to find that in a small town where you have to work harder at making professional connections and finding different problems to solve.
Look, the reason I get so worked up about these issues is that I see librarians hiding in vagaries instead of applying critical thinking to the field and its employment prospects and giving accurate advice to people. It may be that the field is so diffuse it's impossible to give instructional advice. If so, quit acting like what you have to say has anything to do with the real world.
Monday, January 19, 2009
On The Library Job Market
I finally filled out a survey I got from my library school a few weeks ago that asked if I had a gotten a job. Yes, it did ask if it was a library job or outside the field and how much it paid. There was no option for "Yes, I have a library job (two in fact, both part-time) but neither comes with benefits, and what do you consider 'professional' anyway?" The results get reported to the ALA and heavens know they've got a vested interest in delusion.
What frustrates me about librarianship was how one could do everything "right" and still get the response of "you suck" not just from the hiring entities but from people who act as "advisors" in the field. I'm putting that in quotations because honestly there's little practical advice in that forum. And if the job field is so challenging to people doing high-profile work, really I don't think it's entitled or whining to ask what is wrong with the field.
Oh wait, it's me. I never think it's wrong to complain and point out flaw--just sometimes the wrong time to voice them.
Honestly though, when I see jobs like this, I can't help but think a) I dodged a bullet and b) the veil has got to fall sometime.
What frustrates me about librarianship was how one could do everything "right" and still get the response of "you suck" not just from the hiring entities but from people who act as "advisors" in the field. I'm putting that in quotations because honestly there's little practical advice in that forum. And if the job field is so challenging to people doing high-profile work, really I don't think it's entitled or whining to ask what is wrong with the field.
Oh wait, it's me. I never think it's wrong to complain and point out flaw--just sometimes the wrong time to voice them.
Honestly though, when I see jobs like this, I can't help but think a) I dodged a bullet and b) the veil has got to fall sometime.
Sunday, January 04, 2009
Come And Argue With Me
The Liminal Librarian on salary sharing pacts. You know I'll tell you what I make, right? But you could also look it up in the AZ state employees' salary database. I am part of the public record.
The LisJobs Forums are particularly filled with the attitude I cited. If you browse, you'll see what I'm talking about.
The LisJobs Forums are particularly filled with the attitude I cited. If you browse, you'll see what I'm talking about.
Tuesday, September 30, 2008
Time To Ring Some Changes
As most of you know, I got a new job this past week. It's not a librarian job, but it is a position that uses those skills in a new way. I start next week, and if this works out--well, I won't be a librarian any more. How about that?
I'm excited, but not scared. It's been a frustrating battle to find a job and it feels like I've run a long, long time and finally reached the end. It's not where I thought the end was, but hey, it's really nice!
When I think it out, of course I'd wind up in a new profession. In the past year I've gotten rid of most of what I owned, I've left Cleveland and I'm trying to sell the house at a drastically low price without regrets, and I'm recreating so much of my life and my relationships. "Librarian" was a huge part of my identity for a long time, but now I'm moving beyond that into a new professional place.
So you may wonder, "what's going to happen with the blog?" I have some library related and general posts to finish up, including wardrobe analysis freakout, and then I'm probably post intermittently for a while. I can always be emailed, but I am going to concentrate on the new job for a while.
But after that shakes out, you'll get more posts of book reviews, Kerry Reads The Paper, tales of my adventures in Phoenix, dating and living amongst the family, some updated links and a redesign.
And those of you who think I shouldn't be commenting on libraries and librarianship--look, I've worked in libraries since my teens, including 11 years in a professional/paraprofessional capacity, I've been a library user for almost 30 years, and I have a freaking degree. I certainly have a right to my opinion. If you think I don't have that right, go sit on it. I loved being a librarian. I just couldn't find a job. Oh well.
I'm excited, but not scared. It's been a frustrating battle to find a job and it feels like I've run a long, long time and finally reached the end. It's not where I thought the end was, but hey, it's really nice!
When I think it out, of course I'd wind up in a new profession. In the past year I've gotten rid of most of what I owned, I've left Cleveland and I'm trying to sell the house at a drastically low price without regrets, and I'm recreating so much of my life and my relationships. "Librarian" was a huge part of my identity for a long time, but now I'm moving beyond that into a new professional place.
So you may wonder, "what's going to happen with the blog?" I have some library related and general posts to finish up, including wardrobe analysis freakout, and then I'm probably post intermittently for a while. I can always be emailed, but I am going to concentrate on the new job for a while.
But after that shakes out, you'll get more posts of book reviews, Kerry Reads The Paper, tales of my adventures in Phoenix, dating and living amongst the family, some updated links and a redesign.
And those of you who think I shouldn't be commenting on libraries and librarianship--look, I've worked in libraries since my teens, including 11 years in a professional/paraprofessional capacity, I've been a library user for almost 30 years, and I have a freaking degree. I certainly have a right to my opinion. If you think I don't have that right, go sit on it. I loved being a librarian. I just couldn't find a job. Oh well.
Saturday, September 27, 2008
Is Your Inability To Get A Librarian Job A Sign You're A Stupid Jackass?
Apparently, the perennial "Why can't I get a library job?" discussion has erupted on NewLib. I'm not a member anymore, but here's the background on both the list and the discussion, which just goes on and on: it can really hard to get a library job. It's nearly impossible to get one if your only library experience is the required semester-long practicum, or radically different from what path you wind up pursuing after graduation.
The listserv is about 70% normal, pleasant people looking for job advice or offering advice based on their own experiences or are interested in discussing library issues. The other 30% is a nice mix of really stupid people who could never get a job, people who are employed who are jackasses, and people who are unemployed and extremely bitter about it.
Can you get library job? Yes, but it helps to be extremely flexible in your geographic, wage, and other essential requirements. To a certain degree this advice seems to indicate you should either have a sugar spouse or a superhuman ability to perform miracles and live on cheap coffee and no food. Kind of like a supermodel, except you can't even afford drugs!
Look if you can't get a job, any job, something is probably wrong with you. But if you can't get a library job, I'm not so convinced that it's because you're a stupid lazy jackass and and it's all your own fault. It is very competitive, yes. But honestly, more and more if you talk to people the same complaints emerge: the library schools themselves are out of touch with the job market and pass along myths of a shortage, the coursework doesn't prepare students for the job, and admission requirements are so lax and the programs lack rigor and grant a degree almost meaningless and barely academic. That starts to indicate a widespread, systemic problem in the job market and librarian training. And honestly, no matter how much tough love advice is given to job seekers, if their training doesn't prepare them to meet the needs of employers, they are stuck with their best strategy being a DIY approach to fixing the gaps in their background and skills. That's all fine and good, but honestly--if you have to teach yourself everything, why spend $1200 per grad school class?*
Yes, I understand that you always have to invest your own time and money in upgraded skills, no ones owes you a job on a silver platter, blah blah fishcakes, but here's the rub: librarianship and library school programs promote themselves as a 2nd or 3rd career. Until recently, it was unusual to have students in their 20's or just out of undergrad comprise 50% of the class. When I started my degree 5 years ago at 28, I was considered pretty young for the program even if I had been working in libraries since high school. Mandy got grilled by her admissions committee in 1999 when she applied to library school straight from college. If previous experience in libraries isn't necessary for admission to the program, and the profession itself makes a big deal about diversity of experience and background being what it wants in its workforce but a Master's is the prerequisite for anyone to get a professional job, I don't think it's too much to expect the damn degree to thoroughly prepare you for the job.
Back to the lack of jobs-- here's the thing: there's not a lot of hard data to back up either side. But research and anecdotal stories do indicate that there are not many entry level jobs (ie, those that don't have a specific experience requirement), and that those jobs usually don't go to people with little experience or even with transferrable skills and experience from outside the library world.
Folks, I don't have a big message in this or even a dog in the fight anymore. I just read some links and got irritated. All I know is that librarianship is just like anything else--you do the best you can at any given time with what you've got, and count yourself lucky and spare the rest of us false modesty if it does. That's it.
*Yes, this is the what my last 3 credits cost me in 2007. My first 3 in 2003 cost $900, or a little less. At a state school. That's another rant for another day.
The listserv is about 70% normal, pleasant people looking for job advice or offering advice based on their own experiences or are interested in discussing library issues. The other 30% is a nice mix of really stupid people who could never get a job, people who are employed who are jackasses, and people who are unemployed and extremely bitter about it.
Can you get library job? Yes, but it helps to be extremely flexible in your geographic, wage, and other essential requirements. To a certain degree this advice seems to indicate you should either have a sugar spouse or a superhuman ability to perform miracles and live on cheap coffee and no food. Kind of like a supermodel, except you can't even afford drugs!
Look if you can't get a job, any job, something is probably wrong with you. But if you can't get a library job, I'm not so convinced that it's because you're a stupid lazy jackass and and it's all your own fault. It is very competitive, yes. But honestly, more and more if you talk to people the same complaints emerge: the library schools themselves are out of touch with the job market and pass along myths of a shortage, the coursework doesn't prepare students for the job, and admission requirements are so lax and the programs lack rigor and grant a degree almost meaningless and barely academic. That starts to indicate a widespread, systemic problem in the job market and librarian training. And honestly, no matter how much tough love advice is given to job seekers, if their training doesn't prepare them to meet the needs of employers, they are stuck with their best strategy being a DIY approach to fixing the gaps in their background and skills. That's all fine and good, but honestly--if you have to teach yourself everything, why spend $1200 per grad school class?*
Yes, I understand that you always have to invest your own time and money in upgraded skills, no ones owes you a job on a silver platter, blah blah fishcakes, but here's the rub: librarianship and library school programs promote themselves as a 2nd or 3rd career. Until recently, it was unusual to have students in their 20's or just out of undergrad comprise 50% of the class. When I started my degree 5 years ago at 28, I was considered pretty young for the program even if I had been working in libraries since high school. Mandy got grilled by her admissions committee in 1999 when she applied to library school straight from college. If previous experience in libraries isn't necessary for admission to the program, and the profession itself makes a big deal about diversity of experience and background being what it wants in its workforce but a Master's is the prerequisite for anyone to get a professional job, I don't think it's too much to expect the damn degree to thoroughly prepare you for the job.
Back to the lack of jobs-- here's the thing: there's not a lot of hard data to back up either side. But research and anecdotal stories do indicate that there are not many entry level jobs (ie, those that don't have a specific experience requirement), and that those jobs usually don't go to people with little experience or even with transferrable skills and experience from outside the library world.
Folks, I don't have a big message in this or even a dog in the fight anymore. I just read some links and got irritated. All I know is that librarianship is just like anything else--you do the best you can at any given time with what you've got, and count yourself lucky and spare the rest of us false modesty if it does. That's it.
*Yes, this is the what my last 3 credits cost me in 2007. My first 3 in 2003 cost $900, or a little less. At a state school. That's another rant for another day.
Saturday, September 13, 2008
Stop Me Before I Read More
And we've moved onto people posting nonjudgmental instructions on listserv email management (hint, digest mode is your friend), desperately polite attempts to introduce other topics of conversation, and someone who did not put her academic title in her email being snippy about not being addressed as "Dr."
Oh, I am so impressed.
And the Robot Librarian is chiming in in his usual charmless, self-important way.
Someone else took offense with the perfectly polite but strongly worded sentiments of another and wrote that the point of discussion was to learn from one another and suggested rephrasing the sentiment in an utterly milquetoast manner. That's when I started to fight the urge to beat someone with my shoe. First off, strongly worded and clever writing is much more fun to both read and write. It's also a more effective tool to influence your audience. Why wouldn't you use the sharpest knife to get the meat cut?
But what bothers me most about that comment is the sexism, which I'm sure is unintended but nonetheless present. That female poster said to another woman (and indeed the whole of a listserv that's probably about 85% female, as is the profession) that she should tone down her language and to be civil, to compromise--in my interpretation, to be embody traits that are more acceptably female. In a field that's mostly women, we don't need that--we need to be encouraged to fight against our profession's inculcation of indiscriminate niceness and bland conversation, to embrace thorough discourse and analysis in its mess and meaness. Because face it, that niceness and its partner doubt are what prevents us from being taken seriously, from fighting for the tools we need to do our jobs, and from drawing lines of unacceptable behavior.
I frequently wrestle with the notion that librarianship is sexist. It's usually small things like this, little asides designed to get others to tamp down intelligence, sharpness and instinct for the sake of being nice or welcoming. I have also bookmarked some glaring examples from Library Journal that have been published in the last year that I've been meaning to write about because I can't believe no one else has noticed this and thought it worth discussing. Stay tuned.
If anyone wants to check out these listserv posts, email me--they are openly archived, just a little hard to find. And yes, I'm interested in hearing if I'm off my nut or not.
Oh, I am so impressed.
And the Robot Librarian is chiming in in his usual charmless, self-important way.
Someone else took offense with the perfectly polite but strongly worded sentiments of another and wrote that the point of discussion was to learn from one another and suggested rephrasing the sentiment in an utterly milquetoast manner. That's when I started to fight the urge to beat someone with my shoe. First off, strongly worded and clever writing is much more fun to both read and write. It's also a more effective tool to influence your audience. Why wouldn't you use the sharpest knife to get the meat cut?
But what bothers me most about that comment is the sexism, which I'm sure is unintended but nonetheless present. That female poster said to another woman (and indeed the whole of a listserv that's probably about 85% female, as is the profession) that she should tone down her language and to be civil, to compromise--in my interpretation, to be embody traits that are more acceptably female. In a field that's mostly women, we don't need that--we need to be encouraged to fight against our profession's inculcation of indiscriminate niceness and bland conversation, to embrace thorough discourse and analysis in its mess and meaness. Because face it, that niceness and its partner doubt are what prevents us from being taken seriously, from fighting for the tools we need to do our jobs, and from drawing lines of unacceptable behavior.
I frequently wrestle with the notion that librarianship is sexist. It's usually small things like this, little asides designed to get others to tamp down intelligence, sharpness and instinct for the sake of being nice or welcoming. I have also bookmarked some glaring examples from Library Journal that have been published in the last year that I've been meaning to write about because I can't believe no one else has noticed this and thought it worth discussing. Stay tuned.
If anyone wants to check out these listserv posts, email me--they are openly archived, just a little hard to find. And yes, I'm interested in hearing if I'm off my nut or not.
Thursday, September 11, 2008
In Which I Feel Rage, But Mostly Just Sick And Bored Of It All
Oh, THE RAGE, as my friend Mandy would say. Why are librarians so...arrrrgghhh! Frustrating. Dumb. Oblivious. Self-righteous. Pompous. Annoying.
It's coming from my alma mater's listserv these days. First it was a fellow who in all seriousness wondered if he could count a webcomic as his "scholarly publishing" requirement once he hit the big time as an academic librarian. I restrained myself from responding that if he wanted to write webcomics, he should do so (and Jeph Jacques manages to do it as a fulltime job!) and why the hell was he getting a MLIS then or that no, a webcomic isn't what most academic institutions consider a scholarly publication contributing to the body of research and knowledge about the profession. Even if your webcomic presents your findings about federated searching and student populations or bibliometric analysis. And frankly, who the hell would read that?
Oh, it gets better.
So in case you haven't heard, Sarah Palin was of the mind to ban books and fire the librarian when she got elected mayor of Wasilla. Pro-Palin, con-Palin, whatever political affiliations my 5 readers have, I don't care--it is a big deal, and she scares the shit out of me on general principles. So now we've been inundated on the list by people posting links and stories, getting in a huff about "that's not appropriate!" and my favorite "Stop cluttering the listserv with your comments and wasting my time." And when I say inundated, I mean 12 posts over 3 days.
For the love of Mike.
So I am going to have to drop that listserv like I dropped the new librarians, because I just can't take it.
So I have to wonder, as my best options for employment are increasingly coming from non-library sources and the more time I spend away from working in libraries and the more my frustration level with them increases and I worry that my skill level is decreasing--why should I bother? Face it, getting rejected for jobs in your field sucks, and after a while it feels like chasing after a guy who doesn't want you. What would you say to that girl? GO FIND ANOTHER GUY WHO WILL APPRECIATE YOU, right?
"But Kerry," you may ask, "didn't you go through this dilemma in your romantic life? And didn't you just wind up with a crush that has lasted 14 years now, a relapsing and remitting malarial fever of lust and regret?" To which I reply, "YES. AND THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT UP."
It's coming from my alma mater's listserv these days. First it was a fellow who in all seriousness wondered if he could count a webcomic as his "scholarly publishing" requirement once he hit the big time as an academic librarian. I restrained myself from responding that if he wanted to write webcomics, he should do so (and Jeph Jacques manages to do it as a fulltime job!) and why the hell was he getting a MLIS then or that no, a webcomic isn't what most academic institutions consider a scholarly publication contributing to the body of research and knowledge about the profession. Even if your webcomic presents your findings about federated searching and student populations or bibliometric analysis. And frankly, who the hell would read that?
Oh, it gets better.
So in case you haven't heard, Sarah Palin was of the mind to ban books and fire the librarian when she got elected mayor of Wasilla. Pro-Palin, con-Palin, whatever political affiliations my 5 readers have, I don't care--it is a big deal, and she scares the shit out of me on general principles. So now we've been inundated on the list by people posting links and stories, getting in a huff about "that's not appropriate!" and my favorite "Stop cluttering the listserv with your comments and wasting my time." And when I say inundated, I mean 12 posts over 3 days.
For the love of Mike.
So I am going to have to drop that listserv like I dropped the new librarians, because I just can't take it.
So I have to wonder, as my best options for employment are increasingly coming from non-library sources and the more time I spend away from working in libraries and the more my frustration level with them increases and I worry that my skill level is decreasing--why should I bother? Face it, getting rejected for jobs in your field sucks, and after a while it feels like chasing after a guy who doesn't want you. What would you say to that girl? GO FIND ANOTHER GUY WHO WILL APPRECIATE YOU, right?
"But Kerry," you may ask, "didn't you go through this dilemma in your romantic life? And didn't you just wind up with a crush that has lasted 14 years now, a relapsing and remitting malarial fever of lust and regret?" To which I reply, "YES. AND THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT UP."
Thursday, August 21, 2008
Librarianship Is My Bad Boyfriend
So maybe that dream about the job interview in Prescott was prophetic, as I got a postcard in the mail today informing me "other applicant's more closely meeting the needs of the city" were chosen for interviews. The grammar mistake was theirs.
As for the rest of my job hunt: I applied for the academic job up the mountain, but they did not even require a cover letter or any background information other than answers to the questions "Do you have a MLS?" "Do you have reference experience?" and "What is your desired salary?" I have little hope. I have an application out for a part time librarian position out where I interviewed unsuccessfully in April, but who knows. I was turned down for an interview at the unaccredited law school, but really, as it was an unaccredited law school I do not feel particularly bad about that. I had a second interview this week with the state and certainly hope for that, but do not know. I am still on the certification list for a couple of other jobs I applied to in The Large Library System That Is Still Hiring (as opposed to The Large Library System That Has No Money To Hire) but I don't have much luck with that system.
I just wanted to give a little background to my job hunt--I have been applying for any job out here that I am suited for since November. I apply mostly at public libraries because that's where I'm most effective and I do have experience in that area, and that's what's open. But I've also applied at special libraries, the community colleges, and ASU. I have 10 years of special libraries experience in varied industries which I think gets me the boot--I am an odd combination of overqualified, yet not qualified. And it doesn't help that when I started the degree 5 years ago, all the jobs that interested me required it and now--not so much. Thanks, deprofessionalization!
Yes, I also applied for a couple of jobs back in Ohio, but they were pretty special jobs, ones that made sense financially or emotionally/professionally. And I just as deliberately did not pursue other opportunities that would have trapped me.
I am at the point where I'm applying for library jobs that don't even require a MLS, but are also not paraprofessional--just deprofessionalized. I am also applying for any business analyst jobs that seem to fit my background, and admining up my resume. But I honestly am beginning to think that the whole Master's degree was the equivalent of shooting myself in the foot employment-wise.
So please, for the love of Mike, do not tell me any crap about how I haven't been looking that long, that you have to apply for hundreds of jobs before you get one, that to expect that my skills and degree should be applicable and saleable is an "entitled" attitude, that it should be so easy for me to get a job, or stay hopeful.
Just don't say anything. I don't want to hear it, and I may kick you in the shins.
In short, I am beginning to feel about librarianship the way I do about men sometimes--that what is wonderful about me is apparently not what is wanted, that only the younger, stupider and cuter need apply, and nothing good is ever going to happen again.
As for the rest of my job hunt: I applied for the academic job up the mountain, but they did not even require a cover letter or any background information other than answers to the questions "Do you have a MLS?" "Do you have reference experience?" and "What is your desired salary?" I have little hope. I have an application out for a part time librarian position out where I interviewed unsuccessfully in April, but who knows. I was turned down for an interview at the unaccredited law school, but really, as it was an unaccredited law school I do not feel particularly bad about that. I had a second interview this week with the state and certainly hope for that, but do not know. I am still on the certification list for a couple of other jobs I applied to in The Large Library System That Is Still Hiring (as opposed to The Large Library System That Has No Money To Hire) but I don't have much luck with that system.
I just wanted to give a little background to my job hunt--I have been applying for any job out here that I am suited for since November. I apply mostly at public libraries because that's where I'm most effective and I do have experience in that area, and that's what's open. But I've also applied at special libraries, the community colleges, and ASU. I have 10 years of special libraries experience in varied industries which I think gets me the boot--I am an odd combination of overqualified, yet not qualified. And it doesn't help that when I started the degree 5 years ago, all the jobs that interested me required it and now--not so much. Thanks, deprofessionalization!
Yes, I also applied for a couple of jobs back in Ohio, but they were pretty special jobs, ones that made sense financially or emotionally/professionally. And I just as deliberately did not pursue other opportunities that would have trapped me.
I am at the point where I'm applying for library jobs that don't even require a MLS, but are also not paraprofessional--just deprofessionalized. I am also applying for any business analyst jobs that seem to fit my background, and admining up my resume. But I honestly am beginning to think that the whole Master's degree was the equivalent of shooting myself in the foot employment-wise.
So please, for the love of Mike, do not tell me any crap about how I haven't been looking that long, that you have to apply for hundreds of jobs before you get one, that to expect that my skills and degree should be applicable and saleable is an "entitled" attitude, that it should be so easy for me to get a job, or stay hopeful.
Just don't say anything. I don't want to hear it, and I may kick you in the shins.
In short, I am beginning to feel about librarianship the way I do about men sometimes--that what is wonderful about me is apparently not what is wanted, that only the younger, stupider and cuter need apply, and nothing good is ever going to happen again.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)